Why Do Jews Dominate The Diamond Industry?

    Dec 20, 2025

    16134 symbols

    11 min read

    SUMMARY

    TraxNYC hosts a tour of NYC's Diamond District with Martin Rapaport, uncovering how Jewish immigrants built the global diamond trade through history, trust, and economics.

    STATEMENTS

    • The Diamond District on 47th Street concentrates product, money, and expertise, making it the hub for diamonds in the United States.
    • Jewish refugees fleeing Nazi-occupied Europe brought diamonds and cutting skills from Antwerp and Amsterdam, initially working on Canal Street in the 1920s and 1930s.
    • Post-World War II, rising rents on Canal Street pushed the trade to 47th Street's affordable office towers, creating a centralized hub for cutters and dealers.
    • In the 1950s and 1960s, without internet, people relied on personal connections like uncles or cousins to access diamonds in New York.
    • Martin Rapaport published the first diamond price list in 1978, transforming pricing and creating the world's largest online diamond trading network with 1.6 million diamonds worth over $7 billion.
    • The Jewish community built 47th Street after origins on Canal Street in the 1930s and 1940s, shifting due to opportunity and space needs.
    • Jewish history in gems dates back thousands of years, as portable wealth allowed survival during exiles like the temple's destruction.
    • Rough diamonds lose 50-60% of weight during cutting into finished stones, with fancy shapes often cheaper due to better yield from natural rough forms.
    • The Sarine machine scans rough diamonds for imperfections and plans cuts to maximize yield, showing options for polished results.
    • Jack Reese & Sons, a family business since the 1890s, is one of the few factories still cutting diamonds from rough in New York City.
    • About 92% of diamonds are cut in India today, but New York holds onto manufacturing heritage amid tariffs and competition.
    • Memo business allows jewelers to take diamonds on consignment, paying only after sale, based purely on trust without collateral.
    • House of Diamonds, an eight-generation family business, specializes in three-carat-plus fancy shape diamonds and serves as a major memo house for U.S. jewelers.
    • The diamond trade services 20,000 U.S. jewelers, delivering specific stones via FedEx within 24-48 hours due to vast inventory on 47th Street.
    • Jewelry as gifting is ancient, predating money, with examples from biblical nose rings to modern Arab customs giving 10-50% of income as gifts.
    • A single tray at House of Diamonds holds $4 million in value, including a 10-carat DFL Type 2A oval diamond worth $1 million.
    • Trust is the core of the industry; memos loan millions based on honesty, unlike banks requiring collateral.
    • Mark, a Sicilian outsider, succeeded in diamonds by introducing computers, FedEx, and lifetime trade-up policies in the archaic industry.
    • Operating from Rochester allowed Mark to avoid New York's competitive negativity and train staff without bad habits.
    • Retailers like Moses use social media and streaming to sell high-end watches and jewelry, flipping pieces for profit by buying low.
    • The mantra "you make money when you buy" emphasizes acquiring value at 50-60 cents on the dollar and selling at 90 cents.
    • GIA, founded in 1931, integrates education, grading, and research to standardize diamond evaluation, growing from 90 to 3,300 staff worldwide.
    • GIA's advanced machines grade over 20,000 diamonds globally per day, detecting synthetics and colors in seconds.
    • Historical GIA figures like Richard Liddicoat created the diamond grading system in the 1940s, influencing modern standards.

    IDEAS

    • Jewish immigrants turned persecution into portable wealth via diamonds, rebuilding lives and an industry on one New York block.
    • 47th Street's success stems from a unique blend of vast inventory, quick capital flow, and skilled craftsmanship unavailable elsewhere.
    • Without digital tools in the mid-20th century, diamond access relied on familial networks, highlighting human connections over technology.
    • The Rapaport List functions like a stock ticker, standardizing prices and democratizing access to global diamond valuation.
    • Ancient Jewish exile habits of carrying gems explain enduring dominance in high-value, compact trades like diamonds.
    • Cutting rough diamonds involves 50-60% weight loss, but optimizing shapes from natural forms reduces costs for fancy cuts.
    • Sarine technology scans for internal flaws, revolutionizing planning to extract maximum value from each stone.
    • New York's dwindling diamond-cutting factories preserve heritage against offshoring to India and Botswana.
    • Memo consignment thrives on trust alone, enabling million-dollar loans without banks' bureaucracy.
    • Eight-generation families transitioned from royal jewels in Jaipur to specializing in large fancy diamonds in New York.
    • Diamonds service impulse gifting across cultures, from biblical bracelets to modern Arab income shares.
    • A $4 million tray underscores how 47th Street's upstairs vaults hold unseen wealth fueling national retail.
    • Outsiders succeed by modernizing archaic practices like digitizing memos and using overnight shipping.
    • Rochester's isolation allowed innovation without industry gossip, fostering positive business atmospheres.
    • Social media flips luxury items like Rolexes by showcasing street-level authenticity to global audiences.
    • Buying at 50-60% of value and selling low ensures repeat business and mutual satisfaction.
    • GIA's trinity of education, grading, and research creates a self-reinforcing ecosystem for gem standards.
    • Hope Diamond's curse lore contrasts with scientific grading, blending myth and modern analysis.
    • Phosphorescent blues like the Hope glow red under UV, linking rare gems to scientific wonders.
    • WWII-era GIA tools repurposed from army units show gemology's unexpected historical ties.
    • Tariffs and VAT complicate luxury imports, forcing adaptations like domestic factories.
    • Fashion diamonds on apparel modularize luxury, blending jewelry with couture for Paris shows.

    INSIGHTS

    • Historical persecution forged Jewish expertise in portable assets, enabling resilient global networks in diamonds.
    • Centralized hubs like 47th Street amplify economic efficiency through concentrated resources and trust.
    • Technology bridges ancient craftsmanship with modern valuation, maximizing yield from imperfect nature.
    • Trust-based economies outperform collateral systems by fostering long-term relationships over transactions.
    • Cultural gifting rituals sustain diamond demand, embedding economic value in social bonds.
    • Innovation from outsiders disrupts insular industries by applying external efficiencies.
    • Isolation can cultivate unique business cultures free from competitive toxicity.
    • Digital presence transforms street-level authenticity into scalable global sales.
    • Low-margin, high-volume strategies build loyalty in luxury markets.
    • Integrated systems of knowledge creation ensure standards evolve with threats like synthetics.
    • Mythic gem histories enhance perceived value, complementing scientific certification.
    • Global trade barriers accelerate localization, preserving heritage amid globalization.
    • Modular luxury integrates gems into everyday fashion, expanding market frontiers.

    QUOTES

    • "No one's got everything, but the street does have everything."
    • "A diamond legend. Someone who's been pricing every diamond that's been purchased for the past 50 years."
    • "The Jewish people running around from one place to another pick up the habit of working with stones, high value, small piece, and keep it moving."
    • "Planning getting the most out of the money."
    • "I would rather trust an honest person than a really rich person."
    • "You make money when you buy."
    • "If you were to find $100 on the street, would you sell it to me for $50 or no?"
    • "I'm hoping tomorrow will surpass what I saw."
    • "It's a gifting culture, right? We believe in gifts."

    HABITS

    • Waking up early to start the day in the diamond business and handle client needs promptly.
    • Building personal networks through family and community connections for business opportunities.
    • Relying on trust-based handshakes like "Mazal" for deals without written contracts.
    • Continuously learning gemology through hands-on grading and research at institutions like GIA.
    • Scouting hardware and materials personally from sources like Italy for custom projects.
    • Using social media daily to showcase inventory and engage global customers.
    • Adapting to economic changes by maintaining domestic factories despite offshoring trends.
    • Training staff from scratch to instill positive, innovative practices without industry biases.

    FACTS

    • The NYC Diamond District handles more diamond product than anywhere else in the U.S., servicing 20,000 jewelers nationwide.
    • Jewish refugees smuggled diamonds sewn into clothing from Europe, bringing Antwerp and Amsterdam skills to New York in the 1930s.
    • Rough diamonds emerge from the ground in irregular shapes, requiring 50-60% weight loss to become polished gems.
    • 92% of global diamond cutting occurs in India, with New York retaining only a few heritage factories.
    • The Rapaport network accesses 1.6 million diamonds valued at over $7 billion online.
    • Arabs gift 10-50% of annual income as jewelry, reflecting deep cultural gifting traditions.
    • GIA grades over 20,000 gems daily worldwide, detecting synthetics in 1.8 seconds per diamond.
    • The Hope Diamond, a 45.52-carat blue, was mailed uninsured for $2.44 postage in 1958 to the Smithsonian.

    REFERENCES

    • Rapaport List (diamond price standard since 1978).
    • Kimberly Process (co-founded by Martin Rapaport for ethical diamonds).
    • Sarine machine (scans rough diamonds for cut planning).
    • GIA (Gemological Institute of America, grading and education hub).
    • House of Diamonds (eight-generation memo house specializing in fancy shapes).
    • Jack Reese & Sons (1890s family diamond cutting factory).
    • RCI (wholesale diamond dealer).
    • Hope Diamond (famous cursed blue gem graded multiple times).
    • Wittelsbach-Graff Diamond (30-carat blue with red phosphorescence).
    • Biblical breastplate of the high priest (contains diamonds).
    • Isaac and Rachel story (gifting nose rings and bracelets).
    • Jaipur royalty jewels (ancestral trade inspiration).
    • Vicenza gold show (Italian jewelry manufacturing hub).
    • Paris Fashion Week showroom in Le Marais.
    • Rolex watches (high-end retail flips).
    • FedEx (overnight shipping innovation).
    • Computers for memos (digitization tool).
    • Lifetime trade-up policy (original 2000 industry practice).

    HOW TO APPLY

    • Identify a niche like fancy shapes or memos by leveraging family heritage in portable trades.
    • Centralize operations in affordable spaces to attract skilled workers and create a hub effect.
    • Build trust networks through honest dealings, starting with small memos to establish reputation.
    • Scan rough assets with tools like Sarine to plan maximum yield and minimize waste.
    • Introduce modern efficiencies like digital inventory and overnight shipping to outpace competitors.
    • Source globally but manufacture locally to navigate tariffs and preserve quality control.
    • Use social media to showcase authenticity, flipping inventory by buying low and selling transparently.

    ONE-SENTENCE TAKEAWAY

    Trust and heritage built the Jewish-dominated diamond empire, powering a global trade of enduring value.

    RECOMMENDATIONS

    • Cultivate trust in business by prioritizing honesty over wealth in partnerships.
    • Explore outsider perspectives to innovate in traditional industries like diamonds.
    • Invest in portable, high-value skills for resilience during economic shifts.
    • Use technology like scanning machines to optimize resource extraction and planning.
    • Maintain vast inventories to enable quick fulfillment for niche client demands.
    • Integrate social media for authentic storytelling to expand luxury sales globally.
    • Adapt to trade barriers by localizing production and diversifying sourcing.
    • Focus on gifting cultures to sustain demand in jewelry markets.
    • Grade and certify gems rigorously to build consumer confidence.
    • Buy assets at undervalued prices to ensure profitable, low-margin flips.
    • Train teams without industry biases for fresh, positive operational cultures.
    • Blend gems with fashion for modular, wearable luxury innovations.
    • Study historical exiles for lessons on building portable wealth networks.
    • Partner with institutions like GIA for education and research synergy.

    MEMO

    In the bustling heart of Manhattan's 47th Street, the Diamond District pulses as a testament to resilience and ingenuity, largely shaped by Jewish immigrants who fled persecution in Europe. Carrying diamonds sewn into their clothing—portable symbols of wealth—they brought Antwerp-honed skills in cutting and trading to New York in the 1930s. What began as scattered operations on Canal Street evolved into a concentrated powerhouse post-World War II, as affordable office towers drew cutters, setters, and dealers to this single block. Today, the street embodies a trillion-dollar global trade, where trust seals deals via the "Mazal" handshake, and Martin Rapaport's 1978 price list serves as the industry's unyielding ticker.

    At the core of this world lies an intricate process from rough to sparkle. At Jack Reese & Sons, a family outfit since the 1890s, workers scan irregular rough stones with Sarine machines, mapping flaws to yield polished gems—often losing 50-60% of weight but optimizing for fancy shapes that command premium yields. One of the last New York factories cutting diamonds amid India's 92% dominance, it preserves a heritage born of ancient exiles: Jews fleeing temples and empires, clutching gems as life's movable anchors. Upstairs from the sidewalk vendors, memo houses like House of Diamonds stock tens of millions in inventory, loaning stones on faith alone to 20,000 U.S. jewelers for next-day delivery.

    Trust, not contracts, fuels this engine. A $4 million tray—featuring a $1 million, 10-carat oval—might vanish on memo, returned or paid post-sale, a practice banks would shun. Eight generations deep, such firms trace roots to Jaipur's royal jewels, now specializing in three-carat fancy cuts. Gifting underpins demand: from biblical bracelets to Arab customs allocating 10-50% of income to gems, jewelry transcends commerce as cultural ritual. Yet challenges loom—tariffs hike luxury imports, synthetics erode authenticity, and offshoring threatens local craft.

    Outsiders thrive by disrupting norms. Sicilian Mark, entering at 18 after his father's death, digitized memos with computers and FedEx, launching a lifetime trade-up policy that locked in loyalty. From Rochester's isolation, he sidestepped the District's gossip, training unbiased staff to flip gold and diamonds profitably. Retailers like Moses amplify this via streaming, buying Rolexes low and selling transparently: "You make money when you buy," he quips, turning street savvy into viral sales.

    The Gemological Institute of America anchors standards, its New York lab grading 20,000 stones daily with machines detecting fakes in seconds. Founded in 1931, GIA weaves education, research, and certification—echoing legends like the cursed Hope Diamond, graded here despite its trail of misfortune. From WWII repurposed tools to phosphorescent blues glowing red under UV, the institute demystifies myths, ensuring synthetics don't undermine naturals.

    Yet the District's future hinges on adaptation. Fashion innovators embed diamonds in modular apparel for Paris shows, blending couture with gems from Vicenza's gold heartland. As global barriers rise, domestic factories counter offshoring, while Rapaport's network—1.6 million stones worth $7 billion—democratizes access. This unfiltered realm reveals not just bling's business, but humanity's enduring quest for beauty amid flux.

    In unveiling 47th Street's underbelly—from shakshuka dives to vaulted treasures—the tour exposes a self-sustaining ecosystem. Jewish culture exports worldwide through hard-won expertise, proving that in diamonds, as in life, trust and heritage cut deepest.